Heart of the Prairie

PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

I yanked the wheel sharply and then headed back towards Millersville. Once we were under way I turned to look at him. "When did it start?" I demanded. "When did you and she first . . ."

He looked at me as though I was an idiot. "Start? We'd always been in love, even in high school. Her and me were gonna get married after college, as soon as we had enough money to settle down. But then you came along and started panting after her. And her old man said she had to be nice to you for the sake of the town."

He stared at me defiantly. "She tried to refuse. She loved me, not you." Then his eyes lost their fire. "But she loved her old man too, and he kept after her, told her it was her duty, told her she had to do it if she loved him. She never could refuse Daddy," he said bitterly.

"But she wouldn't give me up neither," he said proudly. "So her Daddy worked it all out. I had to live in Arrowpoint, so nobody would ever see Bonnie and me together. But he gave me a job on his place, and every morning I'd drive to the ranch real early. She'd head out of town like she was going to her job in Arrowpoint. Then she'd circle around back to the ranch to be with me."

"But she did go to work in Arrowpoint," I protested. "I talked to her supervisor."

"Well of course she did," Holder replied in exasperation. "She had to make it look real. But she only worked there in the afternoons; she spent the mornings with me."

"I still don't understand. Why all the coming and going back and forth? Why didn't she just meet up with you in Arrowpoint?"

He shook his head in disgust. "Her Daddy said we couldn't be together where folks might see us and start to gossip. But I think he just wanted to have us out there under his thumb."

Then his face took on a look of disdain. "Her old man was a real hard-ass. Once Bonnie left for her job, he made me work like a dog on the ranch all afternoon. But when she was driving home to you at night in Millersville, I'd be driving back to Arrowpoint. We'd pass each other on the way and we'd always do the heart of the prairie thing to show we loved each other even when we were apart.

I glanced over at him again and saw anguish warp his youthful expression. "The night she . . . the night of the accident, her Daddy made me work late, doin' some stupid chores. I thought I'd pass her closer to Millersville, but she wasn't there."

He began to cry openly, the tears running down his cheeks like water over a spillway. "I came up on the accident just a mile or so this side of the river. At first I didn't know who it was, I just knew it was bad. But when I got close enough I recognized her Honda, or what was left of it. The front end was all stove in and she was pinned behind the wheel. Oh, God, Doc, her arm was gone and there was blood spewing everywhere! When I called her name she opened her eyes, looked at me and smiled. And then she died."

He broke down then and began to sob. And though I hated him as my rival for Bonnie, I couldn't help but feel sorry for him. "I'll bet I'm the first person he's been able to tell his story to," I thought. "He's had to keep it inside him all this time, it's a wonder he could function at all."

"You were the one who put that cross up on the highway," I said. He was too emotional to answer, but I knew it had to be the truth. "That's why it said 'Bonnie Miller,' not 'Bonnie Robertson,'" I said, more to myself than to him.

After a while he regained a little of his composure, and he began talking again. It was almost as though he had to get it out. "I called 911, but I didn't stick around because I didn't want to screw things up for Bonnie." He looked up at me with haunted eyes. "When I walked back to my truck, Doc, oh, God, I found her arm." He began to sob again. After that, I couldn't get anything else out of him.

We pulled into Millersville and I drove directly to the courthouse on the square. After I parked my car, I went around, opened the door and gently motioned for him to come with me. He offered no resistance; I'm not sure at that point he even knew where he was.

The Council chamber door had a sign reading "In Session" on it, but I pushed it open anyway. Richard Miller looked up in surprise at my intrusion but quickly smiled at me. "Come in, Dr. Robertson. We were just discussing an important issue and we'd welcome your wise counsel."

"No," I said, "I have an important issue that I want to discuss with you -- all of you." With that I turned and motioned Holden Calloway to come in. Miller turned pale when Holden walked through the door, and I thought it was particularly telling that the others around the table gasped as well. "They all knew," I thought, "they were all in on it."

Miller was the first to recover. "Listen, Mark, I don't know what this boy has been telling you, but . . ."

"Don't bother to lie to me, Richard," I said harshly. "I know the story now, the whole story. You were desperate to get a new physician in Millersville, one who'd stay this time. You were so desperate that you were willing to pimp out your own daughter." I paused to look at the rest of them. "And any one of you would have done the same thing with your own daughters."

"That hardly seems fair," Miller shot back. "What father wouldn't want his daughter to be married to a fine doctor who's respected in the community and can offer her a comfortable lifestyle? I only wanted Bonnie's happiness."

"If you'd really been concerned with Bonnie's happiness, you'd have let her marry the man she truly loved," I said angrily, jerking my thumb at Holden. "But no, you tried to force her to leave him for me. And when she didn't want to give him up, you set Holden up on the side. You turned him into some sort of male mistress, and turned me into an unwitting cuckold -- and all of you knew it."

He held his hands up as if to calm me. "Mark, I know you're upset right now, but you've got to see it from a larger perspective. This town has over a century of history. We're trying to preserve the tradition of small-town America, a heritage to leave to the next generation . . ."

"Bullshit!" I interrupted him. "You weren't interested in tradition or heritage. All you cared about was preserving the value of your ranch." I turned to look at the other commissioners, pointing at them one by one. "And you were worried about the value of your car dealership. And you just wanted to keep the assets growing in your bank. And you were worried about sales in your store."

I shook my head. "None of you give a damn about your sons and daughters and their future. All you care about is your own net worth and how to keep it."

"But a town without a doctor is a town that's dying," Miller said weakly.

"You don't get it," I said harshly. "Your town is already dead. It's rotten to the core, just like the morals of its leaders. I can't wait to get out of here -- you all make me sick."

"You can't go," Miller gasped. "If you leave now, you'll owe the government a ton of money."

I sneered at him. "The money from that life insurance policy you bought for Bonnie ought to cover it," I told him. "And if there's any left over, Holden Calloway can have the rest. I don't want any of your blood money."

I left them seated at the table, silent and staring at each other. I went out to my car and checked the trunk to be sure my bags hadn't shifted and I hadn't forgotten anything important. Then I started toward Arrowpoint.

When I got to the site of the accident, I pulled over and got out to stand in front of the crude little cross one last time. I knew now Bonnie had never loved me, but I'd loved her and it takes a while to get over that. At the same time I hated her for cheating on me, but I pitied her for being forced to give up the one she'd truly loved.

It would take a long time for me to work through all those conflicting emotions. "Maybe I can find some help with that in Oklahoma City," I thought. I pointed my car in that direction and headed out on the long narrow highway running straight through the heart of the prairie.

Please rate this story
The author would appreciate your feedback.
  • COMMENTS
Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous
239 Comments
AnonymousAnonymousabout 1 month ago

Lived in the area my whole life, seen some dumb shit, but nothing like the arm out the window switching lane crap, not even a rumor of it. Also the arm out the window getting severed as a sign vs a normal part of the damage is just stretching the heart thing way to far as it doesn’t even form a heart. And while there would be an effort to keep a doctor. And marrying him to a daughter from the area would be wanted, the “ value of the ranch “ would have little change if the town was there or not.

Omart57Omart574 months ago

Still a great read! R.I.P., FrancisMacomber!

AnonymousAnonymous4 months ago

Ironically it wasn't the doc that was the cuckold., it was the doc that was cuckolding Holden, who was the worst kind a knowing cuckold.

Thr amazing thing is the duplicity of the wife, sure she may have been pimped by her dad with the knowledge of the whole town council... but she was the one that had to sleep and have sex with the doc. So was he that bad that he couldn't make her fall in love with him, or was she that much of a whore that she was cheating on both, by that I mean enjoying both and happy with the arrangement.

Simply no way that a normal monogamously inclined person could pull that level of deception off without it causing psychological issues.

Also $100/200k is chicken feed for a life insurance policy for a doctor wife.

AnonymousAnonymous4 months ago

Again another stupid story about people that simply don't matter. It read like it was in the 1950s but car computers clearly didn't exist then. The inclusion of the 'pregnant option' was just stupid as any autopsy would have covered that. If the town was that small the Doc may well have done the autopsy himself.

secretsalsecretsal4 months ago

Well-done story, though that Heart of the Prairie move is some real Darwin award material. Can understand young dumb kids doing it, but sounds like the kind of thing you grow out of once you get a little more value for your own self-preservation. But considering Bonnie and Holden's messed-up situation, can understand why they'd do stupid things.

Show More
Share this Story

Similar Stories

The Honey Trap You have to use the right bait.in Loving Wives
Trying to Reclaim My Marriage Pushed too far and taken advantage of no more.in Loving Wives
In Her Eyes A husband doesn't like what he sees.in Loving Wives
An Unexpected Reaction To an unacceptable situation.in Loving Wives
Charity Begins Next Door Life isn't fair. So when you fight back, fight dirty.in Romance
More Stories